This butter chicken is my kind of weeknight comfort: a velvety tomato-cream sauce, warming spices that aren’t aggressive, and tender chicken that soaks up every bit of richness. It’s the sort of dish that reads fancy but comes together without drama, and it’s become our family’s go-to when we want something cozy, special, and reliably delicious.

My husband will tell anyone it’s his favorite thing I make — he even requests it for low-key celebrations. Our toddler calls it “red chicken” and insists on spooning extra sauce onto her naan. I love how it travels from quick weeknight to dinner-party dish with just a few tweaks: a longer simmer for deeper flavor, a little extra butter for show, or a sprinkling of kasuri methi (dried fenugreek leaves) at the end for that classic aroma. Making it has taught me to balance patience with efficiency — a good marinade, a hot pan, and a slow finish are where the magic happens.

WANT TO SAVE THIS RECIPE?

Just drop your email here and I'll send it right away! Plus you'll get new recipes every week. Yes please!

Why You’ll Love This Delish Creamy Indian Butter Chicken Recipes

– The sauce is rich and comforting without being overly heavy — bright tomatoes tempered by cream and butter create a silky, balanced finish.
– Accessible ingredients: you don’t need exotic pantry items, and many elements (like garam masala or canned tomatoes) can sit on your shelf for a while.
– Flexible to taste and diet: easily dial up the heat, make it dairy-free with coconut milk, or turn it vegetarian with roasted cauliflower or paneer.
– Crowd-pleaser status: mild enough for kids but layered enough to impress grown-ups.

Behind the Recipe

I learned to treat butter chicken like a layering exercise rather than a single-step sauce. Marinating the chicken — even for a short time — builds a foundation of flavor, and searing the pieces first gives the finished dish better texture. The sauce benefits from patience: cook the tomato base until it loses its raw edge, then finish gently so the cream doesn’t split. Small touches matter: a splash of lemon at the end to brighten, a pinch of sugar if the tomatoes are acidic, and dried fenugreek for that unmistakable butter chicken note. People often rush the finish or add cream too early; the result is a flatter sauce. Let it come together slowly and taste as you go.

★Top Reader Reviews

I recently tried this creamy Indian butter chicken recipe and was amazed by how rich and flavorful the sauce turned out. The instructions were easy to follow, and the result was a dish that felt like a taste of India in my own home. It's a great option for a quick dinner with friends!

– Zara

Shopping Tips

– Chicken: boneless, skinless thighs are my pick — they stay juicy. If you prefer breasts, watch the cooking time to avoid dryness.
– Dairy vs dairy-free: use a full-fat cream or a can of full-fat coconut milk for the creamiest results. If using yogurt in the marinade, choose plain whole-milk yogurt.
– Spices: garam masala, ground cumin, and turmeric are key. If you can, buy whole spices and toast/grind them yourself for a brighter flavor, but good-quality preground is convenient.
– Fenugreek (kasuri methi): optional but transformative; it’s worth buying a small jar. If budget is tight, a small squeeze of fresh lemon helps mimic some brightness.
– Label-reading tip: check yogurt and canned tomato labels for added sugars or unnecessary thickeners if you prefer a clean sauce.

Prep Ahead Ideas

– Marinate the chicken the night before in yogurt and spices for deeper flavor and faster assembly.
– Make the tomato-cream sauce a day ahead and store in the fridge; reheat gently and add the seared chicken at the last minute.
– Chop onions, mince ginger and garlic, and measure spices into small containers the day before; keep them refrigerated in airtight containers for 24–48 hours.
– Store prepped components in clear, labeled containers so evening assembly is fast and stress-free.

Time-Saving Tricks

– Use boneless thighs and cut them into uniform pieces so everything cooks evenly and quickly.
– A hot, heavy skillet sears chicken faster and gives you more flavor in less time—no need to simmer forever.
– Substitute store-bought garam masala only if you’re in a hurry; homemade or higher-quality blends will yield a richer aroma.
– Embrace an immersion blender or food processor for a smooth sauce in minutes instead of long cooking and mashing.
– For weeknights, roast a tray of cauliflower or bake naan from frozen to round out the meal without extra effort.

Common Mistakes

– Overcooking the chicken: cut into uniform pieces and remove from heat as soon as they’re cooked through; they’ll keep warming in the sauce.
– Adding cream too early: high heat can cause curdling. Temper it in toward the end over gentle heat.
– Sauce too thin: simmer gently to reduce and concentrate, or whisk in a little butter or a cornstarch slurry to thicken.
– Under-seasoning: the cream and butter mellow spices — taste and adjust salt, acid, and spice at the end.
– I did this once and assumed more cream would fix a bland sauce; it just made it milky. A humble squeeze of lemon and a pinch of salt fixed it instantly.

What to Serve It With

Serve with steamed basmati rice, warm naan or paratha, a simple cucumber raita to cool the palate, and a bright salad of sliced tomatoes and red onion. Roasted or spiced vegetables like cauliflower, green beans, or sautéed spinach make a nice, colorful accompaniment.

✔Tips & Mistakes

– Warm your serving bowl slightly to keep the sauce cozy; cold plates steal heat quickly.
– Add chopped cilantro at the end for freshness—don’t overcook it or the flavor will fade.
– If rewarming leftovers, do it gently on the stovetop to preserve texture; microwave reheating is fine but can separate the sauce if overheated.

✔Storage Tips

Store in airtight containers in the fridge. It reheats beautifully, but if you sneak a bite cold straight from the container, it still works.
– Keep sauce and chicken together for best flavor; they’ll meld and taste even better the next day.
– Freeze in portioned containers for up to 3 months; thaw overnight in the fridge before reheating gently on the stove.

✔Variations and Substitutions

– Dairy-free: swap cream for full-fat coconut milk and butter for oil or vegan butter; the sauce will have a slightly different but still satisfying profile.
– Vegetarian: roast cauliflower, chickpeas, or paneer cubes and finish them in the sauce instead of chicken.
– Spiciness: increase red chili or add a chopped green chili to the marinade for heat; chipotle or cayenne works in small amounts if you want smokiness.
– Sweetness: swap sugar for honey or maple syrup if you prefer natural sweeteners.
– Acid balance: lemon juice or a light splash of white wine vinegar brightens the final dish—add gradually.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I make this dairy-free?

Absolutely. Use full-fat coconut milk in place of cream and a neutral oil or vegan butter for richness. The flavor will shift slightly but remains deeply satisfying.

How long should I marinate the chicken?

Ideally at least 30 minutes for flavor; 2–8 hours is even better. If you’re short on time, a quick 15–20-minute toss in yogurt and spice still helps tenderize and season the chicken.

Can I use tomato sauce or canned tomatoes instead of fresh?

Yes. Canned crushed tomatoes or a high-quality tomato sauce work well and save time. If using plain canned tomatoes, cook them down a bit to remove rawness and concentrate flavor.

Is there a good vegetarian substitute for the chicken?

Paneer or roasted cauliflower are both excellent. Chickpeas also work for a hearty, protein-packed version—roast or pan-sear them first so they hold their shape in the sauce.

Can I freeze leftovers?

Yes — freeze in airtight portions for up to 3 months. Thaw overnight in the fridge and reheat gently on the stove to preserve texture and prevent separation.

Remember it later

Planning to try this recipe soon? Pin it for a quick find later!